Unfortunately, because many Buffalo Nickels are extremely old, they are often fairly worn. When it comes to giving a Buffalo Nickel a value, there are two things you must take into consideration—age and condition. Naturally, the older the Buffalo Nickel the better, but the age alone is meaningless.

Rare Buffalo Nickels. The 1913-S Type I Buffalo nickel is a scarce issue which retails for around $50 in Good condition. (For a Buffalo nickel to grade at least “Good,” its date and lettering must all be visible.) The 1913-D Type II can bring in $125 in Good condition. The 1913-S Type II is even pricier, at $350 in Good condition.

How Much Buffalo Nickels are Worth: Buffalo Nickel Values & Coin Price Chart. For Sale 2767 Auctions 7 Wishlist 39 Collection 1976. Indian Head Nickel - Mound Type (1913) Designer - Engraver: James Earle Fraser. Metal Composition: 75% Copper - 25% Nickel. Diameter: 21.2 mm. Mass / Weight: 5 grams. Year Details Mintage G (4) VG (8) F (12) VF (20 ...

Grading Buffalo Nickels - How to Video and Descriptions. Visit the in-depth Buffalo nickel grading video, combined with enlarged images and detailed descriptions describing the differences between grades. Dates and mintmarks are only part of old nickel value. Follow the steps to grading Buffalo nickels and it leads to how much your coins are ...

What is a Buffalo Nickel Worth? The value of these nickels will change as there are several years and conditions available. Some Buffalo Nickels are worth more than others, but you must consider several factors including key dates, condition, rarity, grade, and circulation. Some key dates for these nickels include 1913-S Type 2, 1915-S, 1918-D ...